thinking about poverty- a post on Blog Action Day
October 15th, 2008Skype conversation transcript:
On 10/14/08, Melina Chan
[12:39:58 PM] Melina Chan says: heya Cama cama,
[12:40:06 PM] Melina Chan says: Loving my holiday in Laos, although working a little bit!
[12:40:19 PM] Melina Chan says: Really wanted to do a blog for today, but don’t think it will happen! I am on holiday!
[12:40:23 PM] Cameron McGrane says: Fantastic
[12:40:31 PM] Melina Chan says: Hope all is well with you and Canberra is warming up slowly!
[12:40:46 PM] Cameron McGrane says: I thought I was going to pass on my blog for today
[12:40:52 PM] Cameron McGrane says: but just wrapped it up then
[12:41:02 PM] Cameron McGrane says: I so suck at writing!!
[12:41:18 PM] Cameron McGrane says: Thinking about poverty was painful
[12:41:53 PM] Melina Chan says: good work mate!
[12:41:55 PM] Melina Chan says: Am proud of you
[12:41:58 PM] Melina Chan says: how long did it take?
[12:42:08 PM] Melina Chan says: maybe you can help me to bash out a small one now?
[12:44:22 PM] Cameron McGrane says: here it is
[12:44:23 PM] Cameron McGrane says: http://growing.grassrootnetworks.com/
[12:44:34 PM] Cameron McGrane says: first cut. pretty rough
[12:45:59 PM] Cameron McGrane says: I started thinking about it on Monday and nearly had a nervous break down
[12:46:12 PM] Cameron McGrane says: Then nailed this down in an 1h and half
[12:46:19 PM] Melina Chan says: sheesh man, why nervous breakdown?
[12:46:27 PM] Cameron McGrane says: just stressed me out
[12:46:29 PM] Melina Chan says: is there an official deadline? As in 5pm or anything?
[12:46:38 PM] Cameron McGrane says: doubt
[12:46:50 PM] Cameron McGrane says: stressed me out because it was something I had never actually thought about
[12:47:00 PM] Cameron McGrane says: as my post suggests
[12:50:03 PM] Melina Chan says: post looks great!
[12:50:20 PM] Cameron McGrane says: yeh
[12:50:20 PM] Cameron McGrane says: ?
[12:50:22 PM] Melina Chan says: I need to at least try to make one
[12:50:24 PM] Cameron McGrane says: thanks Mel
[12:50:25 PM] Melina Chan says: yeh it does
[12:50:33 PM] Melina Chan says: it’s relevant to most young aussies!
[12:53:15 PM] Melina Chan says: sorry man, gotta go, don’t have a phone and am going to lose the others
[12:57:10 PM] Cameron McGrane says: ok babe
[1:01:12 PM] Melina Chan says: :9
[1:01:14 PM] Melina Chan says: ![]()
[1:01:22 PM] Melina Chan says: I so want to do a blog post
[1:02:01 PM] Cameron McGrane says: thought you had to go
[1:02:03 PM] Melina Chan says: why can’t I just write as easily as I can speak!
[1:03:15 PM] Cameron McGrane says: write what you speak
[1:03:18 PM] Cameron McGrane says: thats how I got mine done
[1:03:22 PM] Melina Chan says: my thoughts aren’t detailed or deep enough, and I tangent
[1:03:23 PM] Cameron McGrane says: pretendend I was talking to myself
[1:03:40 PM] Cameron McGrane says: and tried not filter out “unacceptable” things
[1:03:50 PM] Cameron McGrane says: It does not have be deep or detailed
[1:04:15 PM] Melina Chan says: ok, to write a blog post about poverty,
[1:04:42 PM] Melina Chan says: what could I write
[1:04:52 PM] Melina Chan says: I would like to rant a bit about how I think that a (largely unrecognised) key to poverty alleviation is about win wins in a market environment
[1:05:04 PM] Melina Chan says: and that when individuals, communities and countries
[1:05:12 PM] Melina Chan says: with SOCIAL JUSTICE VALUES
[1:05:24 PM] Melina Chan says: interact with a market system, the outcome will be social justice
[1:05:49 PM] Melina Chan says: that poverty is not a result of capitalism, but is a direct result or manifestation of dominant global values
[1:06:19 PM] Melina Chan says: and about how everyone is keen on looking after themselves, their circle of concern, thus determining their circle of action, hence influence etc
[1:06:30 PM] Melina Chan says: for example, the nature of inheritance through family lines
[1:06:43 PM] Melina Chan says: to perpetuate wealth retention by some, rather than all
[1:06:58 PM] Melina Chan says: where inheritances would be donated to (global?) social causes, community organisations etc
[1:06:58 PM] Cameron McGrane says: So true
[1:08:35 PM] Melina Chan says: http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid=1020
[1:08:41 PM] Melina Chan says: would like to promote this concept too
[1:08:48 PM] Melina Chan says: you see how all my thoughts are all over the place?
[1:09:13 PM] Cameron McGrane says: They are not
[1:09:24 PM] Melina Chan says: http://www.strategy-business.com/press/16635507/11518
[1:09:45 PM] Cameron McGrane says: you have ideas that are more like a thesis than a post ![]()
[1:09:56 PM] Melina Chan says: http://www.intercooperation.ch/sed/product/heierli/main.html
[1:09:59 PM] Cameron McGrane says: being a big N
[1:10:04 PM] Melina Chan says: http://www1.worldbank.org/devoutreach/article.asp?id=485
[1:10:08 PM] Melina Chan says: It;s hopeless
[1:10:13 PM] Melina Chan says: I can never finish a bloody post
[1:10:17 PM] Melina Chan says: it just grows and grows
[1:12:39 PM] Melina Chan says: hey, can you find out how much we pay in Oz for electricity, gas, water ?
[1:13:10 PM] Melina Chan says: Purchasing power parity
http://www.economist.com/research/Economics/alphabetic.cfm?letter=P
[1:14:13 PM] Melina Chan says: there was a great page in that Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid book with a graph -
[1:14:29 PM] Melina Chan says: comparing the cost of essential services in developing vs developed communities, bascially, the poor pay more for these things.
[1:14:38 PM] Melina Chan says: would like to do my own comparing Cambodia and Australia. But considering the time, perhaps I’d better leave that to a future post.
So basically, what was going to follow was some ideas about the role that genuine market engagement leads to competition, which leads to innovation, which leads to greater efficiencies, which leads to lower costs, lower prices, greater access for all! Think about what Richard Branson did to airfares (trying to ignore how flying may be out of the question from an emissions point of view in the not-so-distant future) and how this changed the nature of flying, and size of the market.
But I’ve run out of time, so my unorganised rambling will have to do.
Writing this from a beat-up little internet cafe in Laos charming capital. On holiday with my AYAD (www.ayad.com.au) mates supporting another mate’s fundraising efforts (Regurgitator rocked the Mekong last night for COPE organisation, who do some incredible work with those who have lost limbs due to landmines and UXO (unexploded ordiances).
Peace, love and sticky rice,
Mel
PS - seemingly unrelated, but since we’re on the topic of poverty, completely inseperable The Girl Effect looks at the ‘butterfly effect’ of supporting a single girl in a developing country.
<script src=”http://blogactionday.org/js/805f17f6063e6354c877ecf899800c6fa3f732ec”></script>

